The title page for the first chapter repeats the title on off-white paper with rounded corners: Super Normal Totally Average Very Regular Day in the Life of an Ohio State Student. The central illustration is a sketch of an Ohio State campus building entrance, featuring green double doors under a stone archway with a hanging black lantern. Handwritten text in the bottom right corner identifies this as Chapter 1: Morning.

A 12-panel comic chronicles Grace’s morning. The sequence begins with an alarm clock at 7:00 emitting a loud Beep Beep!, followed by a Smack! on the snooze button. Panels show Grace waking up with messy hair, brushing her teeth, and applying eyeliner. The routine ends with a large drawing of Grace striking a pose in her blue hoodie and jeans with the text "Ta Da!" followed by a tiny panel of her exiting through green dorm doors.

This 16-panel grid shows Grace walking toward a white campus building. After an accidental Squeak!, Grace says, "OH!" and offers a cracker to a sad squirrel, saying, "Aw! I'm sorry buddy... don't be sad. Here, have a cracker!" The squirrel takes it with a bounce bounce, but the mood shifts as dozens of squirrels emerge. Grace nervously tells the crowd, "Ha! Sorry guys, no more!", but they respond with more aggressive Squeak!sounds.

In a 16-panel spread, Grace runs at full speed with the text "OH NO!" and "AAAAAA..." as a wave of squirrels pursues her. She hides behind a tree, whispering, "Come on," but is cornered by a "Squirrel King" wearing a crown and sitting on a jar of Nutella. After a tense exchange with much squirrel squeaking where she pleads, "Lemme go? Please," the king allows her to leave. Grace is shown crawling away with relief and says, "thank you!"

Grace stands by her dorm sink, looking defeated and covered in brown mud splatters. She sighs and says "Don't ask..." Her roommate, Maya, appears as a paper cutout pasted onto the page, wearing blue plaid pajama pants. Maya looks shocked with her mouth open, yelling, "GRACE!" in a large speech bubble. A faint rainbow aura is drawn around the edges of the room to frame the scene.

A profile view of Grace and Kyla facing each other in their shared bathroom, titled Chapter 2: Noon. Grace is on the left in her blue hoodie, looking visibly annoyed. Kyla is on the right with a calm, inquisitive expression. A gray pedestal sink sits between them, and the background mirror reflects a simple pattern of blue and white diagonal stripes.

The left side shows her dorm door, room 2132, with name tags for Kyla and Maya. Panels show her toothbrush, makeup, and her applying blue mascara. The right page features a transformation sequence as she pulls a garment over her head, ending with a panel of Kyla wearing a bright yellow bodice with a blue gemstone and a voluminous pink skirt.

A large, sparkly portrait of Kyla in her full gown, who says, "I guess I am a princess now. This is followed by a knock knock at the door. A person says, "Donut for princess Kyla!" There's an illustration of a donut with pink frosting and the text STRAWBERRY DONUT! Kyla smiles happily with the donut, but the final panel shows her eyes wide in shock as she yells, "CLASS!" and sprints away in her gown, leaving red motion lines behind her.

A trio of animal friends—a startled rabbit, a round pink bird, and a squirrel eating a chocolate bar—run across the ground to the hem of Kyla's dress. One student observer smiles and another looks weirded out. There's a panel showing the front of McPherson Hall. Kyla smiles as another character in a PITT shirt side-eyes here and her group of forest animals. A piece of paper reads Chemistryin ornate handwriting. We see Kyla from the back and then a wide shot of the campus Oval, with someone shouting, "HARPER!"

In a full-page illustration that expands on the previous scene, the camera zooms in on the campus green with a pale blue sky. A domed building stands as a central anchor. Paths cut through the green grass of the Oval like spokes on a wheel, leading toward a central circular plaza. Two small figures (Kyla and Harper) have a conversation. Nearby, a third figure in red walks away down a diverging path.

A hand-drawn comic page marks the start of "Chapter Three: Evening." In the bottom panel, a long-haired character walks through a dark, hatched landscape framed by silhouetted trees. Two speech bubbles capture their internal monologue: "Well that was weird..." and "I think I'm going to study Orton?" The art style features bold block lettering and heavy ink contrasts, giving it a distinct indie-zine aesthetic.

We follow the character to "ORTON HALL," a large stone building with a prominent arched entrance. Standing outside, the character thinks, "Maybe I don't want to study..." The right side of the page uses multiple panels to show the passage of time: the character first laments, "Ughh I do not want to study," before a "1 HOUR LATER" graphic transitions to them declaring, "Okay I am taking a Break!" Finally, while browsing library shelves, they spot a purple book and remark, "Hmm this looks cool!" as the final panel reveals the title: "A Spellbook of Dinosaurs."

The character opens the "Spellbook of Dinosaurs" to a page reading, "CAUTION! Spell to bring back the Dinosaurs. Say: Bring back Dinosaurs!" Enthusiastically thinking "OMG, This is so COOL!" and "Ummmmm Yes!" to the idea of casting it, they shout the incantation: "BRING Back Dinosaurs!" After an initial moment of silence where they remark, "HUH. NOTHING HAPPENED," a massive, jagged sound effect reading "GRRAAH!" erupts, prompting a shocked "WHAT THE HELL?!?" On the facing page, a large Tyrannosaurus rex skeleton comes to life with a roaring "ARGGHHHHH," leaving the character wide-eyed and trembling. As the character flees while screaming "AAHHHHH," the skeleton surprisingly calls out, "WAIT I NEED YOUR HELP!" The scene ends with the character pausing in confusion to ask, "You're a dinosaur. WTH do YOU need MY help?"

The Tyrannosaurus rex skeleton explains its tragic history, stating that long ago, humans invaded Earth and cast a spell to turn dinosaurs into bones so they couldn't fight back. It asks, "Somewhere there is a spell to bring us back.... Will you help me? So yeah that’s what happened." The character, though hesitant, agrees by saying,"I will help," and "But I don't know how...!" while the dinosaur adds, "I miss my friends."

They consult "THE BOOK!" again and find a "Caution! VERY Dangerous Spell... Dinosaurs are Dangerous." The instructions specify that to bring back all dinosaurs, one must say "GEOEH" in runes with a dinosaur. Determined, the character says, "Okay, we can do this!" and "LETS DO THIS!" The character and the T-Rex skull together shout the incantation. Initially, as they look at other skeletons, the character sighs, "I DON'T THINK IT WORKED." However, the magic takes hold, and a blue sauropod and pink stegosaurus appear with a heart between them. The story ends with a celebratory "WAIT!" and the character exclaiming, "We did it! I can't believe it!"

A jagged, red-tinted speech bubble shows the colorful dinosaurs brandishing weapons and declaring, "NOW WE Rage WAR!!" Witnessing the unintended chaos, the character wide-eyed and stunned, thinks, "Oh... MY... I am just going to leave now..." and begins to sprint away while whispering, "Oh... No...". The final large panel shows the character fleeing a building labeled "The Thomas E. AND Patercia." Looking back one last time, she warns herself in a frantic thought bubble: "AVA! NEVER Read books... and don't go to Orton," while saying, "BYE!"

This full-page illustration serves as a title card for the next section of the story, transitioning from black-and-white ink to a more colorful palette. The top half of the page features the words "CHAPTER FOUR" in large, teal-colored block letters, flanked by two yellow stars and underlined by the word "NIGHT."

Below a solid black divider, the scene shifts to "AT THOMPSON LIBRARY." The illustration shows two characters on a light-brown wooden floor in front of a textured red wall. One character, seen from the back with long dark hair, waves goodbye and says, "BYE HARPER!" The other character, Harper, is a girl with brown hair wearing a red sweater and a blue skirt. She waves back with a smile, her speech bubble reading, "BYE AVA!"

Harper begins exploring a seemingly deserted library floor. After stepping out of an elevator, she notes, "HUH... FLOOR'S EMPTY!". While sitting at a desk and thinking, "I need a straight edge," she pulls a book from a nearby shelf, exclaiming, "This'll work!" Her action triggers a hidden mechanism; as a bookshelf slides away with a scrape sound, she stares in shock at the opening, her thoughts punctuated by a large red "WHAT." Discovering a secret passage, she decides, "OOOO!! A distraction from homework. Might as well EXPLORE!"

Upon entering the secret room, she spots an artifact on a pedestal and asks, "Is that a... glowing football!!" As she reaches out to grab it, she is suddenly intercepted by a giant bipedal cockroach labeled "JEFF." The scene ends in a frantic struggle as Jeff and another insect grab Harper by the arms, dragging her away while she screams in large red letters, "LET ME GO!"

Harper is brought before "THE ROACH COUNCIL OF SOUTH OVAL." Confused, she asks, "WHAT DO YOU WANT FROM ME?" A cockroach explains, "YOU HAVE PUT OSU IN GREAT DANGER. Basically that football you touched activated the MIRROR LAKE MONSTER. Now you have to help us DEFEAT it." Harper initially declines, saying, "Yeahhh... so I actually don't want to deal with that." However, the cockroach offers an incentive: "IFFFF you help us, we will never enter Baker Hall AGAIN." Relieved, Harper exclaims, "ACTUALLY?! DEAL!"

The corner of the page reads, "Back in the Underground Lair." The cockroach points to a football-like planning board with O's and X's, saying, "You defeat him by FIRST: Attacking him—THEN you have to throw the football into his mouth." Harper admits, "YEAH so I actually CAN'T throw a football." This leads to a montage sequence labeled "INSERT TRAINING SCENES & RAD MUSIC." Small panels show Harper practicing her throw and running through crowds of cockroaches while screaming "AHHHHH." The training concludes with the council encouraging her, "YOU'RE READY," as Harper adopts a determined expression.

In this final action-packed spread, Harper faces the "BATTLE" against the "MIRROR LAKE MONSTER", who is revealed to be a dinosaur wearing a Michigan jersey with a roar of "RAAAAAA". Witnessing the beast, she thinks, "IT LOOKS EVEN WORSE THAN I IMAGINED." After a teammate notes, "he's a Michigan fan..." the fight commences with Harper landing a PUNCH and a KICK. Despite a moment of doubt where she thinks, "It's not gonna make it!" Brutus Buckeye arrives to help with a "FLYING BRUTUS" maneuver, prompting Harper to exclaim, "IT'S YOU!" Together they deliver a final BAM!that results in a massive explosion and a celebratory "high five!"

Following the victory, the Roach Council awards her a gold medal and declares, "YOU'RE OUR HERO!" They instruct her to "Follow the trail of buckeyes to return home" as she head towards a "PORTAL" marked "touch" while the council cheers "WOO!", "YAY!", and "BYE!" Harper re-emerges "Back at Thompson" with a TRIPand a BAM!After silencing some onlookers with a "SHHHH!", she quickly grabs her things and runs out with a WOOSH! determinedly stating, "I HAVE TO TELL MY FRIENDS WHAT JUST HAPPENED!" as she heads "BACK TO BAKER."

In this final full-page illustration, the four characters stand before a brick wall and speak in unison through a large blue speech bubble where everyone declares, "YOU GUYS WON'T BELIEVE THE DAY I'VE HAD..." The group features Ava, still rendered in a black-and-white hatched style with a small pink dinosaur on her head and a green neon outline, and Harper, who is drawn in color with an orange outline while wearing her gold medal. They are joined by a girl in a light-blue jacket and jeans outlined in purple, as well as Kyla in a yellow gown outlined in yellow. This colorful ensemble brings the various storylines together, highlighting the unique artistic styles used for each character.